E-Gift Cards
E-Gift Cards
Shoe shopping for someone else has never been easier! No more sneaking around to find their size. And you won't have to second guess which design, style or color they'd prefer more. A gift certificate is the obvious choice to assure they get exactly what they want. Order yours today!
GRAND OPENING SPECIAL! Get $25 FREE, with purchase of a $100 gift card. Just add a $25 + $100 gift card (or higher) into your cart & use the code "OPEN25" Limited to one use per customer. Offer ends Monday, December 5th 2022, 11:55pm CST.
OUR GUARANTEE
OUR GUARANTEE
A CUSTOM SHOE STORE YOUR CAN TRUST
Ordering online should never be scary! No matter where you live, ButterMakesMeHappy guarantees your order will deliver safe & reliably. And unlike other websites, we also guarantee that your order will be painted on 100% authentic shoes or your money back!
We’re the custom shoe store with a heart! Not only does butter take pride in our wearable artwork, but also in our customer service. We're a wife & husband ran, small business located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin – USA, creating shoes for over 11,000 happy customers in 43 countries & counting.
IMPORTANT SHIPPING INFO
IMPORTANT SHIPPING INFO
PLEASE ADVISE: My shipping rates & time frames DO NOT include handling. For example, paying for 1-Day Express Shipping doesn't mean that if you place an order today, you'll receive it in 1 day. If an item states there is a 2 week wait, it will ship in 2 weeks using a 1-Day Express shipping service.
When ordering 2+ items with different turnaround times, your items will be mailed together at the latest ship date. For example, if you have 1 item that is Ready-To-Ship & a 2nd item with a 3 week wait, I will ship both items in 3 weeks. So, if you want item to ship sooner, it may be easier if you place 2 separate orders.
SHOE SIZING
SHOE SIZING
We understand that buying shoes online isn't always easy. ButterMakesMeHappy has created a sizing guide to help you purchase with confidence.
•DON’T believe all shoe brands run the same.
-If you compare some of the top 10 shoe brands in the world, you will find that nearly all of them have different measurements.
_
-A brand may say Women’s 9 = Men’s 7. While another brand may say Women’s 9 = Men’s 7.5
-A brand may say that UK 6 =US Women’s 8. While another brand may say UK Size 6= US Women’s 8.5.
_
•DON’T trust anyone’s judgement, but your own.
-The term “true-to-size” is outdated. You know how you like your shoes to fit more than anyone! Do you like your shoes to be loose? Do you like a tighter fit? At the end of the day, you know how you like shoes to fit more than anyone.
Sometimes snooping around a person's shoe closet isn't always option, try these tips.
CUSTOM ORDERS
CUSTOM ORDERS
Searched our entire site & still can't find what you're envisioning? View our Custom Orders page to help bring your idea to life.
RETURN POLICY
RETURN POLICY
Please, consider I’m just a small business & this is a hand-crafted item, which can take many hours or even days to complete, so I cannot offer returns or exchanges, unless there is an error made on my part.
I ask all customers to read my FAQs section for better understanding of sizing & color references. I do believe taking 5 minutes to read this will help you place the order exactly as you need, plus save so much more time & headache.
I set all my orders up to be a positive experience, but mistakes can happen. If there are any errors made on my part, please contact me immediately. I will provide a shipping label, where I can fix or replace the item immediately. You will NOT have to wait the standard time frame a 2nd time.
Cancellations are allowed within the first 48 hours of purchase.
Customer Reviews
YES. YES. AND MORE YES'S
"
My bridesmaids and I ordered these for my upcoming wedding!! They were so sparkly and perfect. Liz was so great to work with. She made me feel so special and the experience felt no different that going to my bridal boutique and selecting dresses. She helped me decide on the right colors because I was on the fence on some things. I appreciated her suggestions but also her taking the time to understand my wedding, theme and personality.
"Bella
11-Jul-2023
butter makes me happy too
"
These shoes were perfect. Butter Makes me happy too. Love the store name. So funny. I loved the package came with a sticker.
"Butter
01-Jul-2023
Finally got lavender converse
"
Great work. Tried to find lavender Converse but couldn't anywhere in my size. They were sold out and discontinued for years. I couldn't believe these were dyed. They looked like the real deal. I just wish they cost the same as regular Converse. I understand they dyed them and I know the shoes cost a lot. But ya know. Still no regrets.
"Reena
14-Jun-2023
Not sure if I already left
"Not sure if my 1st review went through! We loved these for a fathers day gift. He collects flamingos so they were perfect. Looks way better than printed. The detail is so beautiful. And such a fun shoe. Great Fathers Day gift"
DSmith
01-Jun-2023
Appreciated the honesty.
"
I found them on Pinterest. Of course my wedding was less than 2 weeks away. I wanted to see if they could squeeze in an order and ship to me in time. I was willing to even pay extra in shipping. She was very honest that she would try but it would be difficult to purchase my shoe, paint the design and then ship them with enough time to deliver. I feel like she could have taken the money I offered to pay extra, but she wasn't possible. Instead I just placed a regular order--- had them for my honeymoon. Really wish I would have discovered them early but definitely will recommend to any friends getting married! The shoes were amazing.
"McKenna
20-May-2023
SUPER FAST
"
I LIVE IN THE UK. I WAS NOT EXPECTING THEM TO ARRIVE TO FAST. BEAUTIFUL WORK!
"HJ
12-May-2023
"My dream wedding shoes!!! These guys are the absolute best!! "
Oaklie
14-Apr-2023
sorry if I forgot to leave this
"thank you"
C. Stahl
05-Feb-2023
BABY ANNOUNCEMENT READY!
"I had a photoshoot for our baby announcement photos. I thought I was ready. I went on Pinterest to find cute poses, but then I found these mocs! I knew our photographer was already booked with a busy schedule so I didn't want to reschedule. I reached out to the owner of this website seeing if she could make it happen in less than a week. She was so nice and was willing to squeeze them in the schedule at no extra cost, (but I did pay extra to expedite the shipping). And low and behold, the shoes arrived hours before the photoshoot! This really just made everything so much more special. Art work- 5 Stars. Customer Service- 5 Stars! "
So adorable
01-Feb-2023
SO FAST!
"I knew it was probably going to be a tad of a wait because I understand that everything is hand painted, but this came out so fast! Really great attention to detail. I love them so much!! I cannot wait to show them off around the office!!"
Kelly
28-Jan-2023
"Bought this as a gift for my dude friend. Happy seller is able to accommodate large shoe sizes. My friend loves it! Quick shipping."
Dara
31-Dec-2022
"Amazing! So helpful and accommodating! My wife absolutely loved her Hufflepuff Converse on Christmas! Should Harry Potter fans choose ButterMakesMeHappy? Always!"
B
28-Dec-2022
"Seller is awesome! The shoes were painted exactly to my request. My husband loves them and wears them everywhere."
Team Disney
26-Dec-2022
"Fantastic! Exactly as described. Prompt processing and delivery!"
Laura
23-Dec-2022
"Such a fantastic seller to work with. She was remarkably attentive and helped me generously with a size question. The quality of the shoes was wonderful! Highly recommend."
Meredith Cole
23-Dec-2022
"Look amazing, couldn't ask for a better experience"
harvey
22-Dec-2022
"These are even cuter in person. My daughter loves! This is my second order and I can't wait to continue to support this talented women!"
jilliand81
21-Dec-2022
"I love these shoes! They are absolutely perfect!"