Skip to product information
1 of 13


Custom Wedding Color Shoes

Custom Wedding Color Shoes

Regular price $90.00 USD
Regular price $120.00 USD Sale price $90.00 USD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.


Struggling to find shoes that match your wedding colors? Look no further, because custom color matching is our specialty! ButterMakesMeHappy has been creating personalized wedding shoes for the last 8.5 years. We don't believe any bride should stress or compromise when it comes to finding shoes in that perfect shade! We carry hundreds of swatches in many different brands, making our ordering process easy & exciting!

Each pair of shoes are hand dyed & painted using high quality materials with water resistant finishes. Order today & you'll understand why ButterMakesMeHappy is the #1 shoe store for custom color matching!

-includes 1 pair of shoes. Brand, style & size based on your selection.


Don't see your swatch listed? No problem. Just select "OTHER" & give us the details, or send a message with your Order #. We'll provide the address where you can mail us your swatch!

If you don't have a swatch, but want an exact match, I would suggest 3 things…

  1. Go to a bridal shop & look at their swatch book. I had a customer that wanted her shoes to match a dusty pink prom dress she found at thrift store. She stopped in a bridal boutique, looked at the swatch book & picked the color from my selection.
  2. Stop by Home Depot or Sherman Williams. Find a paint swatch card that best matches the shade you'd like & provide us with the color info.
  3. Send us a Pantone color number! We have a complete book with thousands of colors to choose from!


If you're undecided whether to keep the shoes canvas or give it some sparkle, this could be a perfect option for you! Not only will we provide sample swatches of each, we will also include extra incase you also want to see a slightly lighter or darker version! Swatches will be mailed with tracking within 1 week of ordering (or we can e-mail you videos if you request this in the instructions). After you let us know which sample you prefer, we will paint the shoes using this exact method.

Don't think you need samples? That's 100% ok. Our sample add-on is a perfectionist's dream! But if you're a little more lax & trust the process, feel free to save your money!


Within 48 hours of purchasing, we will e-mail you a PDF with your personalizations typed out in 18 different fonts. From there, you can pick out your favorite typeface. We will photoshop the final look onto a pair of shoes to give you a visual & get you pumped! **This is FREE offer that expires February 25th, 2023 at 11:59pm PST. Normally an extra $25 fee.


You are a confident fox that knows exactly what they want. If you choose NOT to have photo proof, your personalizations will be painted with the default layout & font, as seen in photos.


When ordering yours shoes, we ask that you carefully view our Size Chart Helper to find the best fit for you! If you're ready to order, but you need additional time select, "E-MAIL SIZE LATER" & kindly message me within 48 hours with the accurate size & your order #.


Each pair is made-to-order, so if you're looking to tweak the design just ask & we will work with you! Of course, I always suggest browsing through our collections first, but if you still can't find what you're looking for, then lets bring your vision to life with our custom orders process!


The current wait time for this specific listing is 1 week. If there are any delays in our creating process & we cannot make this timeframe, we'll notify you right away via e-mail. Please advise, our estimated delivery helper at the top of the page is NOT a guarantee, but a close approximate timeframe for US & select Canada residents only.


Guaranteeing a delivery date is very hard, considering things like...

-We may have a large wait list in our schedule.

-The mail could delay your package

-Your shoe size could go out of stock

So if you need you're order by a specific date, just send us a message & we'll see what we can do! Please visit our Rush Orders page for more details.



Ordering online should never be scary! No matter where you live, ButterMakesMeHappy guarantees your order will deliver safe & reliably. And unlike other websites, we also guarantee that your order will be painted on 100% authentic shoes or your money back! 

We’re the custom shoe store with a heart! Not only does butter take pride in our wearable artwork, but also in our customer service. We're a wife & husband ran, small business located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin – USA, creating shoes for over 11,000 happy customers in 43 countries & counting.



PLEASE ADVISE: My shipping rates & time frames DO NOT include handling. For example, paying for 1-Day Express Shipping doesn't mean that if you place an order today, you'll receive it in 1 day. If an item states there is a 2 week wait, it will ship in 2 weeks using a 1-Day Express shipping service. 

When ordering 2+ items with different turnaround times, your items will be mailed together at the latest ship date. For example, if you have 1 item that is Ready-To-Ship & a 2nd item with a 3 week wait, I will ship both items in 3 weeks. So, if you want item to ship sooner, it may be easier if you place 2 separate orders.



We understand that buying shoes online isn't always easy. ButterMakesMeHappy has created a sizing guide to help you purchase with confidence. 

•DON’T believe all shoe brands run the same.
-If you compare some of the top 10 shoe brands in the world, you will find that nearly all of them have different measurements. 
•DON’T assume all conversion charts are universal.
-A brand may say Women’s 9 = Men’s 7. While another brand may say Women’s 9 = Men’s 7.5
-A brand may say that UK 6 =US Women’s 8. While another brand may say UK Size 6= US Women’s 8.5.
•DON’T trust anyone’s judgement, but your own.
-The term “true-to-size” is outdated. You know how you like your shoes to fit more than anyone! Do you like your shoes to be loose? Do you like a tighter fit? At the end of the day, you know how you like shoes to fit more than anyone.

Sometimes snooping around a person's shoe closet isn't always option, try these tips.
Not, "size" but sizes! If they say they are a size 8, ask if they're more of a 7.5/8 or an 8/8.5.
gift card is the surest way for a guaranteed to fit. 
You're ready to purchase & don't want to wait! Order now, e-mail us the size later!
Nike Size Chart By ButterMakesMeHappy


Searched our entire site & still can't find what you're envisioning? View our Custom Orders page to help bring your idea to life.


Please, consider I’m just a small business & this is a hand-crafted item, which can take many hours or even days to complete, so I cannot offer returns or exchanges, unless there is an error made on my part.

I ask all customers to read my FAQs section for better understanding of sizing & color references. I do believe taking 5 minutes to read this will help you place the order exactly as you need, plus save so much more time & headache.

I set all my orders up to be a positive experience, but mistakes can happen. If there are any errors made on my part, please contact me immediately. I will provide a shipping label, where I can fix or replace the item immediately. You will NOT have to wait the standard time frame a 2nd time.

Cancellations are allowed within the first 48 hours of purchase.

View full details