Unlimited Shoe Colors

Looking for a specific shoe color, but can't seem to find it? Whether it's a neutral canvas slip on or a sparkly bold high top, ButterMakesMeHappy will make your custom dreams come true. You can place your orders in our Custom Colors Collection, but to give you inspiration we've adding a gallery below for you to see the hundreds of colors we've created over the last 9 years. With our variety of options, you're sure to find a match!