Skip to content

FREE Shipping: endofsummer23

  • Home
  • Shop
    • Weddings
    • Ornaments
    • Holidays
    • Custom Colors
    • Monograms & More
    • Sports
    • Designs & Patterns
    • People & Occupations
    • Little Ones
    • Awareness
    • Food & Drinks
    • Entertainment
    • Nature
    • Places & Travel
    • Jewelry
    • Ready To Ship
    • Browse All
  • About Us
  • View Our Work
  • Reviews
  • Contact
  • FAQs
Log in
    ButterMakesMeHappy
    • Home
    • Shop
      • Weddings
      • Ornaments
      • Holidays
      • Custom Colors
      • Monograms & More
      • Sports
      • Designs & Patterns
      • People & Occupations
      • Little Ones
      • Awareness
      • Food & Drinks
      • Entertainment
      • Nature
      • Places & Travel
      • Jewelry
      • Ready To Ship
      • Browse All
    • About Us
    • View Our Work
    • Reviews
    • Contact
    • FAQs
    Log in Cart

    Item added to your cart

    Reset your password

    We will send you an email to reset your password

    Cancel

    Login

    Forgot your password? Create account
    ButterMakesMeHappy Toast with heart shaped butter on toast

    Quick links

    • Home
    • Search
    • Privacy Policy
    • Return Policy
    • Shipping Policy
    • Terms of Service
    • E-Gift Cards
    • Size Chart
    • Our Guarantee

    Heading

    Please excuse any misspellings, typos, glitches or embarrassing outdated photos you may encounter between now & NOVEMBER 8th 2022.

    Please CONTACT US if you need anything at all & we will be happy to help!

    *Search bar info may not be complete so if you have difficulties finding items, try "Browse All" for now.

      Country/region

      • Afghanistan (USD $)
      • Åland Islands (USD $)
      • Albania (USD $)
      • Algeria (USD $)
      • Andorra (USD $)
      • Angola (USD $)
      • Anguilla (USD $)
      • Antigua & Barbuda (USD $)
      • Argentina (USD $)
      • Armenia (USD $)
      • Aruba (USD $)
      • Ascension Island (USD $)
      • Australia (AUD $)
      • Austria (USD $)
      • Azerbaijan (USD $)
      • Bahamas (USD $)
      • Bahrain (USD $)
      • Bangladesh (USD $)
      • Barbados (USD $)
      • Belarus (USD $)
      • Belgium (USD $)
      • Belize (USD $)
      • Benin (USD $)
      • Bermuda (USD $)
      • Bhutan (USD $)
      • Bolivia (USD $)
      • Bosnia & Herzegovina (USD $)
      • Botswana (USD $)
      • Brazil (USD $)
      • British Indian Ocean Territory (USD $)
      • British Virgin Islands (USD $)
      • Brunei (USD $)
      • Bulgaria (USD $)
      • Burkina Faso (USD $)
      • Burundi (USD $)
      • Cambodia (USD $)
      • Cameroon (USD $)
      • Canada (CAD $)
      • Cape Verde (USD $)
      • Caribbean Netherlands (USD $)
      • Cayman Islands (USD $)
      • Central African Republic (USD $)
      • Chad (USD $)
      • Chile (USD $)
      • China (USD $)
      • Christmas Island (USD $)
      • Cocos (Keeling) Islands (USD $)
      • Colombia (USD $)
      • Comoros (USD $)
      • Congo - Brazzaville (USD $)
      • Congo - Kinshasa (USD $)
      • Cook Islands (USD $)
      • Costa Rica (USD $)
      • Côte d’Ivoire (USD $)
      • Croatia (USD $)
      • Curaçao (USD $)
      • Cyprus (USD $)
      • Czechia (USD $)
      • Denmark (USD $)
      • Djibouti (USD $)
      • Dominica (USD $)
      • Dominican Republic (USD $)
      • Ecuador (USD $)
      • Egypt (USD $)
      • El Salvador (USD $)
      • Equatorial Guinea (USD $)
      • Eritrea (USD $)
      • Estonia (USD $)
      • Eswatini (USD $)
      • Ethiopia (USD $)
      • Falkland Islands (USD $)
      • Faroe Islands (USD $)
      • Fiji (USD $)
      • Finland (USD $)
      • France (EUR €)
      • French Guiana (USD $)
      • French Polynesia (USD $)
      • French Southern Territories (USD $)
      • Gabon (USD $)
      • Gambia (USD $)
      • Georgia (USD $)
      • Germany (EUR €)
      • Ghana (USD $)
      • Gibraltar (USD $)
      • Greece (USD $)
      • Greenland (USD $)
      • Grenada (USD $)
      • Guadeloupe (USD $)
      • Guatemala (USD $)
      • Guernsey (USD $)
      • Guinea (USD $)
      • Guinea-Bissau (USD $)
      • Guyana (USD $)
      • Haiti (USD $)
      • Honduras (USD $)
      • Hong Kong SAR (USD $)
      • Hungary (USD $)
      • Iceland (USD $)
      • India (USD $)
      • Indonesia (USD $)
      • Iraq (USD $)
      • Ireland (USD $)
      • Isle of Man (USD $)
      • Israel (USD $)
      • Italy (USD $)
      • Jamaica (USD $)
      • Japan (USD $)
      • Jersey (USD $)
      • Jordan (USD $)
      • Kazakhstan (USD $)
      • Kenya (USD $)
      • Kiribati (USD $)
      • Kosovo (USD $)
      • Kuwait (USD $)
      • Kyrgyzstan (USD $)
      • Laos (USD $)
      • Latvia (USD $)
      • Lebanon (USD $)
      • Lesotho (USD $)
      • Liberia (USD $)
      • Libya (USD $)
      • Liechtenstein (USD $)
      • Lithuania (USD $)
      • Luxembourg (USD $)
      • Macao SAR (USD $)
      • Madagascar (USD $)
      • Malawi (USD $)
      • Malaysia (USD $)
      • Maldives (USD $)
      • Mali (USD $)
      • Malta (USD $)
      • Martinique (USD $)
      • Mauritania (USD $)
      • Mauritius (USD $)
      • Mayotte (USD $)
      • Mexico (USD $)
      • Moldova (USD $)
      • Monaco (USD $)
      • Mongolia (USD $)
      • Montenegro (USD $)
      • Montserrat (USD $)
      • Morocco (USD $)
      • Mozambique (USD $)
      • Myanmar (Burma) (USD $)
      • Namibia (USD $)
      • Nauru (USD $)
      • Nepal (USD $)
      • Netherlands (USD $)
      • New Caledonia (USD $)
      • New Zealand (USD $)
      • Nicaragua (USD $)
      • Niger (USD $)
      • Nigeria (USD $)
      • Niue (USD $)
      • Norfolk Island (USD $)
      • North Macedonia (USD $)
      • Norway (USD $)
      • Oman (USD $)
      • Pakistan (USD $)
      • Palestinian Territories (USD $)
      • Panama (USD $)
      • Papua New Guinea (USD $)
      • Paraguay (USD $)
      • Peru (USD $)
      • Philippines (USD $)
      • Pitcairn Islands (USD $)
      • Poland (USD $)
      • Portugal (USD $)
      • Qatar (USD $)
      • Réunion (USD $)
      • Romania (USD $)
      • Russia (USD $)
      • Rwanda (USD $)
      • Samoa (USD $)
      • San Marino (USD $)
      • São Tomé & Príncipe (USD $)
      • Saudi Arabia (USD $)
      • Senegal (USD $)
      • Serbia (USD $)
      • Seychelles (USD $)
      • Sierra Leone (USD $)
      • Singapore (USD $)
      • Sint Maarten (USD $)
      • Slovakia (USD $)
      • Slovenia (USD $)
      • Solomon Islands (USD $)
      • Somalia (USD $)
      • South Africa (USD $)
      • South Georgia & South Sandwich Islands (USD $)
      • South Korea (USD $)
      • South Sudan (USD $)
      • Spain (USD $)
      • Sri Lanka (USD $)
      • St. Barthélemy (USD $)
      • St. Helena (USD $)
      • St. Kitts & Nevis (USD $)
      • St. Lucia (USD $)
      • St. Martin (USD $)
      • St. Pierre & Miquelon (USD $)
      • St. Vincent & Grenadines (USD $)
      • Sudan (USD $)
      • Suriname (USD $)
      • Svalbard & Jan Mayen (USD $)
      • Sweden (USD $)
      • Switzerland (USD $)
      • Taiwan (USD $)
      • Tajikistan (USD $)
      • Tanzania (USD $)
      • Thailand (USD $)
      • Timor-Leste (USD $)
      • Togo (USD $)
      • Tokelau (USD $)
      • Tonga (USD $)
      • Trinidad & Tobago (USD $)
      • Tristan da Cunha (USD $)
      • Tunisia (USD $)
      • Turkey (USD $)
      • Turkmenistan (USD $)
      • Turks & Caicos Islands (USD $)
      • Tuvalu (USD $)
      • U.S. Outlying Islands (USD $)
      • Uganda (USD $)
      • Ukraine (USD $)
      • United Arab Emirates (USD $)
      • United Kingdom (GBP £)
      • United States (USD $)
      • Uruguay (USD $)
      • Uzbekistan (USD $)
      • Vanuatu (USD $)
      • Vatican City (USD $)
      • Venezuela (USD $)
      • Vietnam (USD $)
      • Wallis & Futuna (USD $)
      • Western Sahara (USD $)
      • Yemen (USD $)
      • Zambia (USD $)
      • Zimbabwe (USD $)
      Payment methods
      • American Express
      • Apple Pay
      • Diners Club
      • Discover
      • Meta Pay
      • Google Pay
      • Mastercard
      • Shop Pay
      • Visa
      © 2023, ButterMakesMeHappy Powered by Shopify
      • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
      • Opens in a new window.