Shop By Collection
View all-
Custom Colors
Explore hundreds of shoes that you never knew existed! Whether it's a...
-
Food & Drinks
Step into something tasteful (pun definitely intended) with our deliciously fun shoes!...
-
Little Ones
Let your little one's personality shine with our custom painted shoes. Our...
Our interview with Radio Milwaukee
Local designers (and dairy lovers) gearing up for Culture By Design
By Jen Ellis
Featured Wedding Shoes
-
Amethyst Wedding Glitter Converse
Regular price From $135.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$135.00 USDSale price From $135.00 USD -
Gold Glitter Wedding Shoes
Regular price From $110.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$110.00 USDSale price From $110.00 USD -
Navy Glitter Wedding Shoes
Regular price From $110.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$110.00 USDSale price From $110.00 USD -
Black Bridal Vans
Regular price From $120.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$120.00 USDSale price From $120.00 USD -
Wine Glitter Wedding Converse
Regular price From $135.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$135.00 USDSale price From $135.00 USD -
Custom Caricature Couples Shoes
Regular price From $210.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$210.00 USDSale price From $210.00 USD -
Custom Floral Shoes
Regular price From $140.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$140.00 USDSale price From $140.00 USD -
Custom Infinity Initial Shoes
Regular price From $80.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$80.00 USDSale price From $80.00 USD -
Just Married Shoes
Regular price From $80.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$80.00 USDSale price From $80.00 USD -
Mrs. Potter Wedding Shoes
Regular price From $120.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$120.00 USDSale price From $120.00 USD
Custom Colors
-
Wine Glitter Adidas Nizza Platform Shoes
Regular price $115.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$145.00 USDSale price $115.00 USDSale -
Gold Glitter Shoes
Regular price From $90.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$90.00 USDSale price From $90.00 USD -
Purple Glitter Shoes
Regular price From $90.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$90.00 USDSale price From $90.00 USD -
Pick Your Color - Sparkly Glitter Old Skool Vans
Regular price $120.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$120.00 USDSale price $120.00 USD -
Navy Glitter Shoes
Regular price From $90.00 USDRegular priceUnit price per$90.00 USDSale price From $90.00 USD
Meet the Makers
About UsOUR GUARANTEE
A custom shoe store you can trust
Ordering online should never be scary! No matter where you live, ButterMakesMeHappy guarantees your order will deliver safe & reliably. And unlike other websites, we also guarantee that your order will be painted on a 100% authentic shoes or your money back!
We’re the custom shoe store with a heart! Not only does butter take pride in our wearable artwork, but also in our customer service. We're a wife & husband ran, small business located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin – USA, creating shoes for over 10,000 happy customers in 43 countries & counting.
Unlimited Shoe Colors
-
View Our Colorful Portfolio
Looking for shoes in a specific color, but can't find it? We will make your wildest custom dreams come true! For 9 years we've been specializing in dying, painting &...
View Our Colorful Portfolio
Looking for shoes in a specific color, but can't find it? We will make your wildest custom dreams come true! For 9 years we've been specializing in dying, painting &...
