data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/999e6/999e62006e62197cf3ef3aa869160d0baec2afb9" alt=""
WE'RE #1 FOR A REASON!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/23613/23613794acfc79ffb381a2a9ec0a554cdb625b7d" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f61a3/f61a30626b303b803eee0fa242675f6c626a4fa3" alt=""
WE SPECIALIZE IN CUSTOM COLORS & GLITTER SHOES!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/231d6/231d686e420138ca7495850a4d63ea701885e4f6" alt=""
Shop By Collection
View all-
Custom Colors
Explore hundreds of shoes that you never knew existed! Whether it's a...
-
Food & Drinks
Step into something tasteful (pun definitely intended) with our deliciously fun shoes!...
-
Little Ones
Let your little one's personality shine with our custom painted shoes. Our...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc078/cc078b990aa01444f604b2e6cc2c59877f28742b" alt=""
Our interview with Radio Milwaukee
Local designers (and dairy lovers) gearing up for Culture By Design
By Jen Ellis
Featured Wedding Shoes
-
Amethyst Wedding Glitter Converse
Regular price From £109.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£109.00 GBPSale price From £109.00 GBP -
Gold Glitter Wedding Shoes
Regular price From £89.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£89.00 GBPSale price From £89.00 GBP -
Navy Glitter Wedding Shoes
Regular price From £89.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£89.00 GBPSale price From £89.00 GBP -
Black Bridal Vans
Regular price From £97.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£97.00 GBPSale price From £97.00 GBP -
Wine Glitter Wedding Converse
Regular price From £109.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£109.00 GBPSale price From £109.00 GBP -
Custom Caricature Couples Shoes
Regular price From £169.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£169.00 GBPSale price From £169.00 GBP -
Custom Floral Shoes
Regular price From £113.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£113.00 GBPSale price From £113.00 GBP -
Custom Infinity Initial Shoes
Regular price From £65.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£65.00 GBPSale price From £65.00 GBP -
Just Married Shoes
Regular price From £65.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£65.00 GBPSale price From £65.00 GBP -
Mrs. Potter Wedding Shoes
Regular price From £97.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£97.00 GBPSale price From £97.00 GBP
Custom Colors
-
Wine Glitter Adidas Nizza Platform Shoes
Regular price £93.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£117.00 GBPSale price £93.00 GBPSale -
Gold Glitter Shoes
Regular price From £73.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£73.00 GBPSale price From £73.00 GBP -
Purple Glitter Shoes
Regular price From £73.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£73.00 GBPSale price From £73.00 GBP -
Pick Your Color - Sparkly Glitter Old Skool Vans
Regular price £97.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£97.00 GBPSale price £97.00 GBP -
Navy Glitter Shoes
Regular price From £73.00 GBPRegular priceUnit price / per£73.00 GBPSale price From £73.00 GBP
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bf106/bf1062fe1f79fd6944d0dfda67a1b4ba4c042b89" alt=""
Meet the Makers
About UsOUR GUARANTEE
A custom shoe store you can trust
Ordering online should never be scary! No matter where you live, ButterMakesMeHappy guarantees your order will deliver safe & reliably. And unlike other websites, we also guarantee that your order will be painted on a 100% authentic shoes or your money back!
We’re the custom shoe store with a heart! Not only does butter take pride in our wearable artwork, but also in our customer service. We're a wife & husband ran, small business located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin – USA, creating shoes for over 10,000 happy customers in 43 countries & counting.
Unlimited Shoe Colors
-
View Our Colorful Portfolio
Looking for shoes in a specific color, but can't find it? We will make your wildest custom dreams come true! For 9 years we've been specializing in dying, painting &...
View Our Colorful Portfolio
Looking for shoes in a specific color, but can't find it? We will make your wildest custom dreams come true! For 9 years we've been specializing in dying, painting &...
Subscribe to our emails
Be the first to know about new collections and exclusive offers.